
Many baseball fans and analysts are quick to point out the shift in the dynasty of the New York Yankees occurred with the signing of Jason Giambi in December 2001.
This, of course, was a turning point within the organization. The Yankees had just suffered an excruciating game seven loss to the Arizona Diamondbacks. Had they won, it would have been their fourth World Series championship in a row and their fifth in six years. But the baseball gods decided that due to the infield playing shallow, Luis Gonzalez would drop a flare just over the dirt behind shortstop- a spot Derek Jeter usually occupies. Craig Counsell would raise his arms, come dashing home, and I would vomit.
This clearly was not supposed to happen.
New York had just recovered from 9/11. They had also somehow managed to rebound from a 2-0 game deficit with four of the most dramatic homeruns in postseason history (including two in back-to-back nights by Scott Brosius off Byung-Hung Kim, who apparently went on suicide watch, and Derek Jeter's game-winning shot in extra innings that sent the World Series into November.).
But anyway, the Yankees lost. And it didn't sit well with owner George Steinbrenner. Beloved Yankee Tino Martinez's contract had expired, Giambi was available. Next thing you know, Tino is off to St. Louis to play with La Russa and Giambi is stumbling around first base.
The contract was a mind-blowing (at the time) 7 year/$121 million dollar pact. Giambi was coming off a tremendous season with the Oakland Athletics, he had just won the MVP in 2000, and was widely regarded as a clubhouse leader.
Now I liked and still like Giambi. He was an admitted juicer, came clean about it, suffered the consequences and the scrutiny. God knows he had more than enough opportunity to fold his tent. But for some reason, he kept plugging away... nowhere near living up to the expectations of that mammoth contract. The guy came up with some clutch hits, always had a great OBP and NOBODY seems to remember in that pivotal 2003 ALCS game against the Red Sox (the Aaron Boone game), that Giambi hit two homers off Pedro Martinez that kept the Yankees within striking distance. And I'll never forget how badly he struggled with steroids-related injuries along with a benign tumor that practically erased his 2004 season. When he returned in 2005, he REALLY struggled through May. There was talk of sending him down to the minors, everyone thought he was done. Yet he found some way to rebound during the last four months of the season, ultimately winning the 2005 Comeback Player of the Year award.
But his signing was an omen of bad things on the horizon.
The organization abandoned the philosophy that helped them achieve the dynasty from 1996-2001 (you could stretch it to 2003, maybe). And that philosophy consisted of defense and homegrown talent (Jeter, Bernie Williams, Mariano Rivera, Jorge Posada, Andy Pettitte).
Tino Martinez was a vacuum at first. Giambi struggled playing catch. First base does not seem like too difficult of a position to play as a spectator, but it does require being on the receiving end of a ton of plays over the span of a 162- game season. Brosius left the hot corner leaving a huge void, Williams aged ten years overnight, Jeter lost a step, and the less said about Soriano's skills at second base the better.
The homegrown talent was getting older, slower. Yet, instead of infusing youth from the farm system, the organization decided to decimate it instead by trading for aging superstars like Gary Sheffield, Kevin Brown, Randy Johnson, Jon Lieber, a second helping of Orlando Hernandez, a practically-retired John Olerud... the list goes on.
I'm not going to mention Alex Rodriguez. There deserves to be an article about the New York Yankees without bringing up fucking ARod.
I admire Giambi's resilience the same way I admire Mike Mussina. Both of those guys were thrust into a difficult situation when a confused organization was struggling to rebuild.
Both of these guys are also insanely rich.
How will Giambi be remembered? Probably not for his MVP, or his jovial clubhouse candor, or the way he would hammer the right-field porch at Yankee Stadium. Not for the World Series ring he never won; since 2004, the Yankees still haven't made it past the first-round.
He's going to be remembered for the steroids. And because his name was smeared, ultimately his numbers won't really matter that much... even though they are very impressive. But from 2002-2008 when the egomania in the Yankee clubhouse rendered the atmosphere just a tad bit snippy, Giambi seemed like one of the only guys out there having fun (who can forget the infamous mustache?). In that regard, he reminds me of CC Sabathia.
And of course, Derek Jeter.
Good luck, Jason.
AGE YEAR TEAM G AB H 2B 3B HR R RBI SB CS SO BB HBP SH SF IBB GDP BA OBP SLG
24 1995 OAK-A 54 176 45 7 0 6 27 25 2 1 31 28 3 1 2 0 4 .256 .364 .398
25 1996 OAK-A 140 536 156 40 1 20 84 79 0 1 95 51 5 1 5 3 15 .291 .355 .481
26 1997 OAK-A 142 519 152 41 2 20 66 81 0 1 89 55 6 0 8 3 11 .293 .362 .495
27 1998 OAK-A 153 562 166 28 0 27 92 110 2 2 102 81 5 0 9 7 16 .295 .384 .489
28 1999 OAK-A 158 575 181 36 1 33 115 123 1 1 106 105 7 0 8 6 11 .315 .422 .553
29 2000 OAK-A 152 510 170 29 1 43 108 137 2 0 96 137 9 0 8 6 9 .333 .476 .647
30 2001 OAK-A 154 520 178 47 2 38 109 120 2 0 83 129 13 0 9 24 17 .342 .477 .660
31 2002 NY_-A 155 560 176 34 1 41 120 122 2 2 112 109 15 0 5 4 18 .314 .435 .598
32 2003 NY_-A 156 535 134 25 0 41 97 107 2 1 140 129 21 0 5 9 9 .250 .412 .527
33 2004 NY_-A 80 264 55 9 0 12 33 40 0 1 62 47 8 0 3 1 5 .208 .342 .379
34 2005 NY_-A 139 417 113 14 0 32 74 87 0 0 109 108 19 0 1 5 7 .271 .440 .535
35 2006 NY_-A 139 446 113 25 0 37 92 113 2 0 106 110 16 0 7 12 14 .253 .413 .558
36 2007 NY_-A 83 254 60 8 0 14 31 39 1 0 66 40 8 0 1 2 1 .236 .356 .433
37 2008 NY_-A 145 458 113 19 1 32 68 96 2 1 111 76 22 0 9 5 6 .247 .373 .502
1850 6332 1812 362 9 396 1116 1279 18 11 1308 1205 157 2 80 87 143 .286 .408 .534
- Jack
No comments:
Post a Comment