
If friends are merely strangers on a first-name basis, then I imagine that family are the friends we make when we are just too young to know better.
You remember those friends. We all had them. They're not necessarily bad people (although perhaps they could be)- but there are no enforced commonalities. Most of the time you only have one thing in common- proximity. Well, exchange that proximity for blood and you've got yourself a family. And it just so happens that blood promotes proximity. Next thing you know, you're a bunch of goons posing for a photo. Does that family in the picture actually look happy to you? Of course not. Would you like to know why? Of course you would.
It's because they are staring at us instead of staring at each other.
Sure, there is an abundance of "touchy-feely"... but c'mon, gimme some eye contact, people.
Anyone can place a consoling hand upon a shoulder. You can even do that accidentally, especially for the brief prescribed moment that is captured by a camera. But to find the invisible sight-line connection, that's a little bit of extra work. It requires some searching. Maybe it's just me, but I find a quiet desperation in a captured smile.
Not all smiles mind you, but the captured ones. The ones where you can tell the person has been holding the smile for about five seconds before you witnessed it.
The ones that win me over are the ones where the person has no idea a picture is being taken. And the majority of the time, the individual has no idea the picture is being taken because they are making eye contact with someone else. Bottom line: you're never going to convince me of your happiness through a structured scenario... it has to be at least somewhat voyeuristic if you want to utilize a captured image. It's all a matter of advertising the product really. That's why the family stares at us instead of sharing gazes with each other. It's an attempt to sell themselves through the promotion of contentment and unity. And I don't know these guys... they could be a legitimately close-knit bunch. But I doubt it.
And that's just the problem- familial complacency. Because individuals biologically exist as families, they usually believe that is good enough.
And sadly it's not. Family relationships are alot like every other kind of relationship- except fidelity is an expected requirement not a mere suggestion. I understand alot of intimate relationships use fidelity as a requirement as well (and that's all well and good, Hands Across America for the committed couples of the world)... but temptation always exists. When was the last time you were tempted to cheat on your family? The answer is "never"... mainly because we never realize that's an option. Sure, there are broken families. There are also fixed families. There are also fixed families that get broken again. But, unlike a boyfriend-girlfriend/husband-wife scenario, we don't identify any form of exit strategy. Your family can be broken, but you can never break up with your family. Are we stuck with our families? Are our families stuck with us? It's the ulimate "I'm feeling smothered, I need some space" relationship.
But what if I started another relationship with a new family? A new bunch of strangers that touch each other's shoulders and smile in unison. I'm not talking about adoption or marriage or anything like that. I'm talking about the ramifications of cheating on... I don't know... your mother. Sure, it sounds creepy. But what if you just didn't get along with your mother. So you embraced a new woman as a maternal figure on a completely emotional level; you loved this woman for all the reasons for which you were supposed to love your biological mother. It happens all the time believe it or not. But because we don't classify it, we don't dignify it (if such a thing as cheating on your mother can ever be dignified).
One thing I know for certain about blood, it can sure be messy.
- Jack
Photos are similar to mirrors in a way. Neither can really show the truth. I agree that candid pictures are best, but the problem with the true smiles you capture when a person is looking at someone else is that it's usually NOT the photographer they're looking at. So all you can ever really get is a smile on the periphery--happiness that is directed at someone else.
ReplyDeleteI love your last sentences. They always tie up the story in some fashion, but usually have nothing to do with what you said. :)
ReplyDeleteYou are so full of it until you are intoxicated with foul odors. The only person/people that speak in this capacity are the ones who have no realization of actuality, just some formality that makes them think they are above the norm simply because they don't dare to be different, they strive for it for no other reason but mere complacency.
ReplyDeleteHmmm... let's see, Anonymous... just how many five-dollar words ending in "y" can we throw into a comment to make it sound legitimate?
ReplyDeleteDid you use the word "actuality" because you wanted to use the word "reality" but you had already said "realization" and it came across as redundant?
So my insistence on abstract thought renders me complacent? By that rationale, does knowledge make me dumber? Are these the musings of an absolute idiot? Does real power and understanding lie in social acceptance?
Would everything be okay if I wrote an entry on how warm and satisfactory that family photograph makes me feel because it's supposed to make me feel? Or is it better that I actually FEEL a little creeped out by a bunch of fake smiles and awkward hand gestures.
Shhh. The healing process will commence shortly.
- Jack
Well, should you ACTUALLY know the definition of realization, you would find that it is an awareness, to realize, to understand whereas Actuality is for certain, which my case in point being that it is not redundant at all.
ReplyDeleteAnd as far as you writing about how warm things were around you....you have missed my point, could've been all the five-dollar words... I don't think the word family should inspire anyone to instantly feel warm, nor do I feel that a large population feels that way. Do I think that you should feel creeped out? Only if you feel the same way amongst strangers as you do with those posing.
So. Two responses and about two-hundred dollars worth of misplaced words later, how do you feel?
ReplyDeleteIn all actuality.
- Jack
How can it be considered complacent to question people who might be complacent? And what is the actuality that you are being so adament about, Anonymous?
ReplyDeleteHow do I feel? Let's see...I feel that blood is only thicker than water if you choose for it to be. I feel that maybe just having the same blood type could link people tighter than genetics.Supposedly, one is always to choose "blood over water". Blood meaning family, obviously. With that said, one should define family.
ReplyDeleteI feel that girls do cheat on their mothers, given their mothers were/are not present. I don't think that cheating on your family is frowned upon, just maybe another disappointment.
I don't believe that one is just an image in a photograph, there is always a story, maybe the person taking the picture is the grandfather, hence everyone looking at the camera (or the photographer).
Are we restricting maternal infidelity to just mothers then?
ReplyDelete- Jack
Genetics was never the issue being discussed. But there sure is some primal bond formed between most mothers and their newborns. Does the baby have any discernible quality at birth to activate the maternal bond other than genetics? not really. Family is a bond you can never get away from even if you want to. You might have nothing in common, you might be mistreated or misunderstood, but you still have a mother. You still have a father. You might fight with them or not even know them, but you have siblings. Even if the bond is in title only, it's still there. And it's because we have all these defined relationships that I think everyone does a double take when they hear someone has replaced a parent. It might not be exactly frowned upon--of course some parents are awful--but the information always stands out. Even if someone agrees with your reasons to choose another parent figure, that will become a part of your identity. And that only emphasizes how familial ties are traditionally viewed. But I think that's kind of the point. Would you choose your specific family members if you had a choice? Maybe not. But the relationships were defined before you had a say.
ReplyDeleteAs for photographs, there might always be story. But I'd rather it be a story about how people feel interacting candidly at a specific moment than a story about how they all gathered and posed with what they think might resemble their real smiles to capture a planned moment in time. And if Grandpa was taking the picture, that might be significant. But try to look at the photographer and ignore the camera while at the same time posing for a shot. I don't think that's how it usually happens.
If Grandpa was the photographer maybe it was because they were at a family gathering and maybe, they had no camera stand, or maybe he wanted to have a pic of those he love that didn't include him. Maybe, as opposed to remembering what was going on that day through random shots, he wants to remember them as a person with the memories that he has established with them per say. And as far as pics go, traditionally, growing up, we were always told to pose, leaving the candid shots to magazine photographers, and/or 7 year old girls. Would I rather have candid shots, yes, very much. I'm simply stating that traditionally, we (myself), have always been taught to stand beside each other and say cheese.
ReplyDeleteIf genetics weren't in discussion, then I have interpreted what 'Jack' was stating a bit differently.
Family is no where near a bond unless you make it one. You can no way have a bond with someone that you do not know. Not even after birth. Only time develops bonds and families, or any relationship for that matter. I guess you could be referring to title only, but then define family? Maybe that's where my opinion differs. Family to me is a bond, something created over time; people that you can call and ask how long to cook a turkey for, or just to call no matter the time. They are the ones that no matter what, they love you unconditionally. I don't think you can get that from a "title bond".
No need to put my name in quotations. Jack is Jack.
ReplyDeleteI see where you're coming from to a certain extent. But I don't believe time plays a role. Mainly because I believe time is the ultimate red herring. I think there are bonds we do not establish and that we may never escape from.
For example, how we are given birth.... how we are given death. We associate family as those responsible for our creation. Who knows? Maybe on the other side.. our new families are those responsible for our demise.
- Jack
No need for reference, I was not implying that Jack was anyone/anything except Jack.
ReplyDeleteHow is time a diversion of subject?
I wouldn't associate "family" as the responsible party for my creation, but that brings an entirely different topic up.
Because time is technically a man-made thing. All time is relative. So I don't think family can be defined by an established variable such as time. If time is removed and everyone just exists, family will still be there.
ReplyDeleteYour mother is an inherent member of your family. You emerged from the birth canal of your mother. Therefore, family is the responsible party for your creation.
- Jack
I don't think any of us disagrees that there are different kinds of familial bonds. Yes, Anonymous, many people emotionally adopt surrogate family members. And many people have friends they feel closer to than family. You can reject family, but the ties still bind. By saying, 'I have no mother,' you're really saying that you have a mother you have chosen to disown.
ReplyDeleteObviously a mother is a mother a brother is a brother a father is a father etc. My point is it does not make you family, it just makes a connection, but none of any importance or value.
ReplyDeleteFamily is not a part of my recreation, a woman was a part of it. One of the many definitions of family is a group of people who have something in common.