Monday, February 16, 2009

Letting the Cat Out of the Bag


Many stories confused me when I was young.
Many also bored me.
There were even more that I just couldn't get enough of.
None, though, left me more unsettled and disturbed than Dr. Seuss' The Cat in the Hat.
Confusion, isolation, frustration.
I felt all of these things after the final page was turned.
Because even as a child, I knew that something was a little off. I mean, just what was this story actually about?

Mom leaves to go somewhere. It's raining outside. The brother and the sister have nothing interesting to do (despite the fact they own a quite verbose and responsible goldfish) so they are content to just stare out the window. Then, the Cat shows up. All hell breaks loose. The house is destroyed. The kids have to be almost hospitalized for anxiety. The Cat cleans up and leaves. Mom comes home. And everything goes on just like normal.

Ohhhhhhh-kay.

I grew to hate this story. Where were the morals? Was there any resolution? Who is the Cat? Where did he come from? Has the whole world gone crazy?

It wasn't until college that I actually glanced at the book again. Finally, I reached the conclusion that there is alot going on in The Cat in the Hat. Stuff that I didn't see as a child, stuff my parents probably never picked up on either as they were reading it to me. But the brilliance in Dr. Seuss' story is that it never connects the dots at all. It provides the reader with context clues forming a "charming" little narrative about disaster averted. But upon connection of these dots, a darker tale emerges.

First of all, where is Mom going? It's the middle of the day, it's raining, there's no babysitter. These kids clearly have no business being home alone. Secondly, why are the kids so sad? I only say they are sad because they gaze forlornly out the living room window in some kind of Prozac-esque depression calmly waiting for their Mom to return. That, in itself, paints a very grim picture.

Then, the damn Cat arrives. The Cat exists solely as an Agent of Chaos (in this regard, he would get along extremely well with Heath Ledger's Joker, think about that). He does not attempt to come across as mean-spirited or hurtful in any way, but he is deeply nuts- perhaps even a little sociopathic. He tests the emotional limits of the children, forcing them to go further into disobedience than they could possibly imagine. The Cat wishes the brother and sister would just chill out and embrace destruction. When not creating the actual mayhem for them to embrace, he constantly goads the children into getting in touch with their inner selves- basically stating the only way to grow as individuals is to confront your weaknesses and destroy that part of your individuality (in this regard, he would get along extremely well with Brad Pitt's Tyler Durden, think about that).

Meanwhile, the goldfish functions as the Voice of Reason. The Voice of Reason exists as the antithesis for the Agent of Chaos. To prove his superiority, the Cat embarasses the goldfish at every given opportunity forcefully damaging the credibility of the Voice of Reason. It was a masterstroke from Seuss to make the Voice of Reason a fish in a bowl. It makes Chaos much more tempting when the Voice of Reason is confined by water and space.

But where did Mom go? We do not know. All we know is that she will be home in a minute. This is a fact that elevates the household destruction from suspenseful to downright nerve-wracking. It is not until the Cat cleans up, leaves, and Mom returns, that we realize the role the mother played in all this. She clearly had gone somewhere sketchy that afternoon. She knows this, the children know this (they exhibit their disapproval through their bored depression). Yet, neither one are willing to acknowledge it. This is why the Cat appears. The Cat in the Hat exists as a smoking gun manifested by Mom. This smoking gun is necessary in order to cleanse the conscience of the parent. If the brother and sister do not mention the destruction of the home, they are just as irresponsible as Mom herself.

Mom never made any false illusions about what she was up to. But it has clearly given her a guilty conscience. Yet whatever dividends she was paid during her absence on that rainy afternoon, they are far greater than telling the truth. By this rationale, she cannot excuse her disappearance- in fact, it may even happen again. However, the children now have a guilty conscience as well due to them covering up the destruction of the house.

With both parties possessing guilty consciences, the playing field is now level.

Mom is beyond suspicion. Mom is now beyond even the Voice of Reason.

This was last as long as she effectively employs Chaos to distribute the blame.

We all need to be at fault for something. After all, this is why the Cat exists.

- Jack

1 comment:

  1. while not quite to your extent, ive always felt this story had a stronger subtext. good read.

    ReplyDelete