Saturday, February 21, 2009

Silas or Finnegan?

This isn't a joke- although it sounds like one.

Sadie sits by herself on a Saturday night at Charades, a local pub in Somewhere, USA. A man named Silas walks inside and sits down next to her. He buys Sadie a vodka tonic and they engage in conversation for roughly ten minutes or so. Then, Silas gets a cell phone call and excuses himself to walk outside.

Once he is gone, Harv the bartender says to Sadie, "Careful, Sadie. He is a man with a past."

Then another man, this one named Finnegan, walks into Charades and sits down next to Sadie. He also buys Sadie a vodka tonic and they engage in conversation for roughly ten minutes as well. Finnegan also gets a cell phone call and excuses himself to walk outside.

Once he is gone, Harv the bartender says to Sadie, "Careful, Sadie. He is a man with no past."

So who should Sadie be more cautious of... Silas or Finnegan?

- Jack

2 comments:

  1. I would have to go with Finnegan. While most people would like to avoid getting too involved with someone with a past such as Silas, at least someone WITH a past is familiar. We've all heard it, and we all know pretty much what it means. But Finnegan, he's a real mystery. Someone with NO past? Everybody has a past, so if he has none, then he is the unknown. How is someone supposed to respond to something like 'that guy has no past?' What does that even mean? At least with Silas, Sadie has some idea of what to expect.

    Then again, the unknown and unexplainable aren't always bad things. In fact, sometimes they are the BEST things (see Unidentified Flying Resurrection and comments...) So, following this thread of logic, Sadie should be more cautious of Silas. At least she knows there are bad things about him. Finnegan may be a mystery, but he could be a good mystery.

    Sorry I took up so much space and didn't really answer your question.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'd be cautious of Harv, the bartender and the doubt he instills. Who said pasts were a bad thing? Pasts are what makes us who we are and they are nothing to be afraid of. Shame on Harv for opening his mouth and putting doubt into Sadie. Let her figure it out for herself.

    ReplyDelete